Plot: Lucas must make a difficult decision regarding Brooke. Haley considers having sex with Nathan
Chad Michael Murray
James Lafferty
Bethany Joy Lenz
Sophia Bush
Hilarie Burton
Barry Corbin
Craig Sheffer
Moira Kelly
Paul Johansson
Barbara Alyn Woods
Bryan Greenberg
Emmanuelle Vaugier
Zachary Hermann
Kwame Heyward
J.R. Rodriguez
Brett Claywell
Thomas J. Wright
Billy Dickson
Rick Clark
Stephen Thompson
Karyn Usher
Jennifer Cecil
Mark B. Perry
Mark Schwahn
Mike Kelley
David Blake Hartley
Gregory Prange
Stan Salfas
Clarinda Wong
Lindsay Wolfington
Craig Fincannon
Frank Godwin
Gavin DeGraw
Kelly Jefferson
Tim Bellen
Teresa Field