Ashley Newbrough. Ashley Newbrough was 32 in Christmas Love Letter as 'Amalie Hess'.Tilky Jones. Tilky Jones was 38 in Christmas Love Letter as 'Ian McCallister'.Chanté Bowser. Chanté Bowser was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Demi Jones'.Jackie Prucha. Jackie Prucha was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Mrs. Crabtree'.Ben VanderMey. Ben VanderMey was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Joseph Harrington'.Pierce Lackey. Pierce Lackey was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Will Rivers'.Geraldine Leer. Geraldine Leer was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Karen'.Izzy Herbert. Izzy Herbert was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Marty McCallister'.Charity Hitchcock. Charity Hitchcock was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Dottie'.Denise Hillis. Denise Hillis was >> in Christmas Love Letter as 'Waitress'.Damián Romay. Damián Romay was 41 in Christmas Love Letter as 'Fisherman Dom'.Stacy Johnson. Stacy Johnson was >> in Christmas Love Letter as '(uncredited)'.